Not every back pain starts in the spine
Superior cluneal nerve branches travel through the back muscles and thoracolumbar fascia, cross the iliac crest and supply the skin of the upper buttock. A narrow fibro-osseous passage can become an entrapment point.
Entrapment can mimic spinal pain and produce buttock or leg radiation (“pseudo-sciatica”). Because the nerve is sensory, the entrapment itself should not cause muscle weakness.
Three useful clinical clues
- A small focal tender point over the posterior iliac crest.
- Pressure or tapping reproduces the familiar pain and sometimes its radiation.
- A local anaesthetic block clearly reduces pain for the duration of anaesthesia.
Walking, standing, rising from a chair and lumbar flexion, extension or rotation may aggravate symptoms. Radiation need not follow one dermatome.
Diagnosis and differential
Diagnosis is clinical and begins by localizing the painful point. A block can support the diagnosis but cannot prove that this is the only pain generator. MRI and other tests are mainly used to exclude disc disease, stenosis, hip or sacroiliac pathology, fracture, tumour, infection and other causes.
Nonoperative treatment
Activity adaptation, physiotherapy, medication and an anatomically or image-guided block may be used. A block can also be therapeutic and may be repeated selectively. Substantial but temporary relief with recurring disability may lead to surgical discussion.
Surgical solution
The tender point and estimated nerve route are marked, the branches are identified under magnification, and compressive fascia and scar are released. The aim is not spinal surgery; it is decompression of an external sensory nerve.
When pain has multiple sources, decompression may address only the cluneal component. Complete relief cannot be promised.
Clinical evidence
In Kuniya and colleagues’ prospective study, 113 of 834 patients with low-back and/or leg symptoms met the clinical criteria and received a block; 19 with persistent symptoms underwent surgery. Average pain and disability scores improved, but the operative cohort was small and the study was not randomized, so individual outcomes cannot be predicted.
Reference
- Kuniya H, Aota Y, Kawai T, et al. Prospective study of superior cluneal nerve disorder as a potential cause of low back pain and leg symptoms. Journal of Orthopaedic Surgery and Research. 2014;9:139. doi:10.1186/s13018-014-0139-7